God’s Not Dead Movie Review
I just
got back from seeing the new movie “God’s Not Dead” and I was pretty impressed with
the movie as a whole. I will preface this by saying that the style of the movie
is very clichéd in places and some people may view the set up as unbelievable.
Please understand that this is a movie and that I believe that the message is
what is important here, and there are quite a few messages to be had. Before I
get there I should back up and start from the beginning.
The
movie opens up at the beginning of every main character’s day. The characters
involved are Josh Wheaton, a Christian freshman starting at university (I can’t
recall if they ever name what university this is set at, but I do recall LSU
apparel in the background so maybe it is in Louisiana), Philosophy Professor
Jeffery Radisson, Mina, a Chinese student named Martin, a news investigator/blogger
Amy, and Reverend Dave. Each character is going about their morning routine,
and the scene finally settles on Josh going to register for his classes. As he
picks out his humanities elective, and introduction to philosophy course, the
student registering Josh recommends that he pick a different instructor for the
course. Josh insists that he take the course because he doesn’t want to
rearrange his whole schedule. Now there are several side stories that will all
come together at the end of the movie, but for this review I will cover them
sequentially so that I am not bouncing back and forth.
Josh
attends his first lecture of the semester and Professor Radisson makes his
entrance. He gives a speech about a host of intellectuals who are/were leaders
in their field and are/were atheists. Radisson then gives a speech over how
belief in God is foolish in this day and age and gives his students slips of
paper. He tells the students to write “God is Dead” and sign the paper so they
may skip the section over debating whether or not God existed. Everyone but
Josh signs and turns in the paper. Josh explains that he is a Christian and
that he cannot do what Radisson wants him to do. Radisson instead assigns Josh
to give 3 lectures over the topic “God is not dead”. Josh then speaks with his
girlfriend about the issue and she tells him that he should drop the class or
simply tell Radisson that God is dead. She launches into a speech over how she
is at her third choice school because she wants to be with him and that failing
this class would ruin Josh’s chances of law school. Josh refuses to give in
after speaking with Reverend Dave and prepares his lectures without her
knowing. The first of Josh’s lectures comes and he chooses to start with the
evidence for the Big Bang. Toward the end of the lecture, Radisson interjects
with a quote from Stephen Hawking “because there is a law of gravity, the
universe can and will create itself out of nothing.” This quote stumps Josh for
the time being and the lecture ends there. Josh’s girlfriend discovers that he
went ahead against her wishes and she breaks up with him. Afterwards, Josh is
in the library researching for his second lecture and runs into Martin. Martin
asks Josh why he is doing this and Josh explains that to him, God is very much
alive and Josh does not want to disappoint him. The second lecture comes around
and Josh provides an answer to Hawking’s quote by quoting my personal favorite
apologist, John Lennox. He explains that Hawking’s quote contains circular
logic and that nonsense is still nonsense, even when spoken by a famous
scientist. The rest of the lecture contains some arguments against evolution as
a blind, unguided process, but this lecture is relatively short. After the
class leaves Josh asks Professor Radisson what happened to him that made him so
angry at God. Professor Radisson asks Josh what kind of God would allow a 12
year old boy to watch his mother die of cancer and not answer his prayers to
Him to heal her. This question will set the stage for the third lecture, the
problem of evil. The movie takes a step back and focuses on the other
characters, as well as Radisson’s wife Mina choosing to leave him. This event
enrages Radisson and causes him to change the framework of the last lecture
into one of a debate. They have a quick exchange over the previously mentioned
problem of evil. Josh brings up that evil is allowed due to the gift of free
will that God gives to all humans, for us to be able to freely choose God and
to love Him and one another. Radisson scoffs at this and the conversation turns
to the students observing and why each party is defending their point. Radisson
wants to “free” his students from the burden of ancient superstition, and Josh
wants to give the students the ability to choose whatever worldview that makes
the most sense. Josh then turns on Radisson and confronts him again with the
question of why he hates God. After being pressed, Radisson admits to him
having nothing but hate for God and Josh adds the stinger of why Radisson hates
someone that supposedly doesn’t exist. After this, both Josh and Radisson turn
to the students to see their decisions. A few moments of silence and Martin
starts an avalanche of the entirety of the class declaring that God is not
dead. Josh, Martin, Mina, and others attend a Newsboys concert. During the
concert, Radisson has a change of heart and goes to the concert to try and
reconcile with Mina. On his way to the concert, Radisson is hit by a driver who
immediately flees the scene. Reverend Dave is at the scene with Jude, an
African missionary. They rush to Radisson’s aid and find him dying. Dave speaks
with Radisson about Jesus and if Radisson would accept him. Radisson decides to
accept Jesus and passes away minutes after. The movie then concludes with
multiple cuts to the other character involved and then the credits roll.
That
being done, I can give synopses for the multiple side stories that are
occurring throughout the movie. The first that I will cover is Ayisha, a Middle
Eastern student who is a recent convert from Islam. She is hiding her faith
while in the presence of her family, but is discovered when her brother tells
her father that she was listening to a sermon by Franklin Graham. Her father is
outraged and kicks her out of the house. She goes to see Dave about whether or
not she made the right choice. Dave explains that following Christ sometimes
means laying down everything that one has to follow him. Ayisha overheard Josh
talking about defending his faith at the beginning of the movie and congratulates
him during the concert when she sees him in the crowd.
Dave’s
story begins when he picks up Jude from the airport. They discuss their
ministries and Dave expresses his view that he feels like he isn’t doing
anything important. Jude lets him know that any small part helps to advance the
kingdom of God. Throughout the movie Dave is ministering to Josh, Mina, and
Ayisha. He encouraged Mina when she came to him after being verbally abused by
Radisson at a dinner party for speaking up about her belief in God. Dave tells
Mina that she is seeking to affirm herself through her relationship with
Radisson and that her self-worth should be coming through herself and God. This
talk is what motivates Mina to leave Radisson. There is a running gag within
the movie where Dave and Jude are trying to leave on a vacation to Disney World
and Dave cannot get his car, or his rental car, to start. Finally Jude talks to
Dave about the importance of faith in every situation of life and convinces
Dave to try one more time to start the car and leave toward the end of the
movie. Dave follows the advice and the car starts, and Dave and Jude start on
the trip that will lead to the two of them to the accident that claimed
Radisson’s life.
Martin
is present for all of Josh’s lectures, and Martin is moved toward belief in God
by them. When he tries to share is faith with his father in China, his father
cuts him off continually because he is afraid that they are being monitored. He
is convinced that God exists by the end of the lectures and decides to become a
Christian because of Josh’s courage and faith.
Mina
starts of the movie by visiting her mother in a care facility. She has dementia
and is in declining health. Mina calls her brother Mark, a powerful
businessman, and begs him to go visit her because she may not have much time.
MArk finally goes and vists her toward the end of the movie, and his mother had
a moment of clarity and informs him that his lifestyle of sin and looking out
for number one is going to trap him when his time on this earth is over. Mina
makes a mistake buying a wine bottle for Radisson’s dinner party and speaks out
about the existence of God during said party, which causes the majority of the
attendees, including Radisson, to verbally berate Mina. She speaks to Dave, and
leaves Radisson following Dave’s advice.
Amy is
Mark’s girlfriend, a tough reporter who likes the ambush interview tactic. She
starts the movie finding out that her car has been burglarized and her GPS has
been stolen. After a phone call with her Mark, she makes it to her first
appointment of the day, an interview with Willie and Korie Robertson. She tries
to get the couple to trip on her questions or contradict each other, but they
do not. After a while in the movie, we come back to Amy at the doctor’s office
saying that she has cancer. After further testing, she discovers that the
cancer is untreatable, and she becomes depressed and angry. After consulting
Mark for support, he breaks up with her because it is inconvenient for him to
take care of her. She attends to concert to try the same tactics on the
Newsboys. They turn the questions on Amy and say that she is there because she
is hoping that Christianity will turn out to be true. They pray with Amy and
she accepts Jesus as her savior.
I
believe that is the majority of the movie covered; now I can give my thoughts.
I think this movie as a movie is what the Christian music scene was when it was
getting started. It is a very good movie for those who are already believers,
but those who do not share our view may not be as avid fans of it as we are. I
think the philosophy and apologetics presented here are pretty solid, if not a
little basic in places. There are definite character archetypes, but that is
just a part of the writing. Some people have probably drawn the parallel
between an old story where a student presented an infallible argument to a
philosophy professor and that student turned out to be Einstein. I would agree
with the majority of this, but there is uniqueness to the movie. The setting
could just as easily be the discussion between a believing and non-believing
student, but Hollywood must scale up the setting for the sake of appeal.
Naturally the conclusions drawn are in the favor of the existence of God, I
mean it’s in the title of the movie, but the arguments are presented in a reasonable
manner in my opinion. In all of the stories presented here, I think many of us
can relate to one or more of these stories, in my case I was moved by the main
story as I am a college student and I have seen something like this story,
although it was not a professor but simply the sheer number of atheist students
that I have met and talked with. If you get a chance to see this movie before
it is out of theaters, I would highly recommend it, Christian or not. This
movie is unlike any other out there currently, except Son of God, because it is
bringing the big questions of life to the big screen and the main stream media.
I would hope to see many more movies like this from all sides so that people who
are not versed with advanced philosophy may at least see the basics of the
schools of thought represented. May God bless you and have a good rest of your
day.
Comments
Post a Comment